Sitting here the day after Thanksgiving, I know one thing I am thankful for: I never ran into anybody like Debbie Lafave or Lisa Lynette Clark or Amanda White when I was 14 or 15 or 16 years old. One’s a school teacher; one’s a youth minister’s wife; and Lisa Lynette was a boy’s best friend’s mother. Two of these women had sex with boys hardly old enough to shave; the other one was a Baptist and only got as far as talking dirty.
Lisa Lynette got pregnant and married her boy; she is 37, he is 15. The judge who married them said he thought she looked more like she was in her 20s when he performed the ceremony there in front of Lisa Lynette’s SUV in the driveway. It would seem that a woman approaching 40, who looked to be in her 20s would have been in a good position to get herself a man, maybe even somebody with a job, but she didn’t or wouldn’t or couldn’t. Maybe she had had it with men by then. She even sent the kid love notes and dirty pictures of herself -- and no teen-age boy throws out his dirty pictures. The boy lived with his grandmother and of course she found them. Granny said the boy already was in therapy and she had hoped to speak to his therapist before turning Lisa Lynette in, but one of those love notes (along with what were described as “lurid” – a wonderful old-timey, quaint-seeming, grandmotherly word, “lurid” – photographs) made her snap and she turned in the child-molesting, cradle-robbing, harlot, hussy, lurid and painted Jezebel of a whore. The note that pushed Granny over the edge said: “I love you so much. I’m yours forever.” She must have realized that “forever” just might mean different things to a grown woman and a growing boy and didn’t want her grandbaby caught up in the confusion. It took the authorities so long to act on the complaint that the boy and his best friend’s mom tied the knot and even had a wedding photo snapped by the judge. This all took place in north Georgia and seems to have been legal under state law, but Lisa Lynette was arrested anyway, for sexually molesting her husband because he was under age.
Debbie Lafave was the schoolteacher. She hooked up with a 14-year old boy at the middle school where she taught down in Florida. She was 25 last week when she pleaded guilty to two counts of lewd and lascivious behavior with a minor. The boy told police Debbie was lots more lewd and lascivious than that. Boys are prone to brag about such things, even when they are grown men, but he said he had sex with her three times in four days, at least once in a classroom at the middle school, and another time in the backseat of a car while his 15-year-old cousin drove them around. Debbie also performed oral sex on the boy several times, including one time at her house. The boy did not say what he was doing while Debbie was performing oral sex. Whether oral sex is even sex is a matter of debate involving both U.S. presidents and the pre-teens and teen-agers who live on your street; some say yes, some say no, but it seems clear which side of the debate the authorities come down on in Florida. Debbie got three years of house arrest, seven years of probation (a plea bargain kept her out of prison) and has to register as a sex offender. Debbie is blonde and some people might say she was cute as a button. Some guy sitting around having a few drinks with his friends at the bar after work might see her walk by and say, “I wouldn’t kick her out of bed,” and his friends would nod slyly and grin and they would all have another beer. Her husband said Debbie had mental problems, got a divorce anyway, then ran Debbie down on national TV, saying she should have done some hard time in prison just like a man caught in a similar situation.
It was probably Amanda White’s good Christian raising that kept her from hopping right in the sack with her chosen fella, but she apparently spent her spare time creating a fantasy world for a 15-year-old boy whose picture she claims to have seen once on a friend’s cell phone. Amanda is the wife of the youth minister at Victory Baptist Church in Burnet, Texas. Amanda is 27 years old and somebody’s mom. She created a 16-year-old persona she cleverly called “Mandy” by taking the “A” off and adding a “y” and set about writing her young chap lots of cards and letters, having phone sex with him and sending him gifts that included bras, underwear, condoms and personal lubricant (no lurid photographs were mentioned in the newspaper). He always picked up the letters and other stuff at the youth minister’s house (where “Mandy,” apparently a shy sort of girl, was using Amanda as a go-between) and he probably said, “Thank you” when Mrs. White handed them to him, as any well brought up (though clearly somewhat dense) Texas boy would say to the preacher’s wife. Mandy? Amanda? Who knew? He finally caught on and told his mom, but not before he had asked Mandy to go to the prom with him (she was a no-show). He told police he thought Mandy wanted to meet him for sex. But it would have been condomized safe sex, slippery with personal lubricant. Or at least that was probably the fantasy Mandy and her teen-ager shared. Mandy was always asking, but Amanda seems never to have put herself in position to receive. She is charged with felony solicitation of a minor.
When I try to think like a teen-age boy (something I finally gave up as I was approaching 40, like most American men do), I realize I probably wouldn’t have kicked any of them out of bed. As my friend Paul once said, most boys and men “don’t cull much” when it comes to that sort of thing. But when I was a teen-age boy, grown up women like Lisa Lynette and Debbie were out of a boy’s reach (unless that boy’s daddy was willing to pay for one). Amanda would have been more in the realm of possibilities. She created a lubricated fantasy world for her little fella -- and teen-age boys live in a hormonally charged world fraught with slippery fantasies. At least that is the world I grew up in.
Lots of my fantasies involved a real woman who, even when she had a whip in her hand, looked like a woman a boy could trust. Her name was Bettie. She looked sweet and she looked like a woman. She had curves like our mothers and high-heeled shoes (highest-heeled shoes) our mothers wouldn’t be caught dead in. Her hair was black and long, but she had short girlish bangs. I must have seen hundreds of pictures of her: Bettie in her underwear; Bettie in her bikini; Bettie in her bed; Bettie standing up straight or bending over; Bettie tied up or tied down; Bettie with her whip (and sometimes, for reasons I still cannot fathom, with her whip and her toy monkey). I never thought of the photographs as lurid, though I am sure my grandmother would have turned Bettie in. I even found a picture of Bettie in a magazine in the dresser drawer where my father kept his underwear and socks; I was home alone and snooping around. I still remember that picture in particular: Bettie from the back, bent at the waist, very high-heeled shoes, bare skin showing, lots of leg, the right breast glimpsed in profile, but all of the essentials covered up, looking back over her shoulder at me. I couldn’t imagine why my father would have such a thing, so I stole it and put it in my own dresser drawer. I didn’t understand why I wanted to look at such a thing either, but I didn’t put it back (strangely, my father never asked).
Bettie Page is an old woman now. But she really isn’t. She made the world a sexy place to live. She still does. I suppose my parents found Bettie in the bottom of my underwear drawer when I left home a few years later and I would love to have seen the looks on their faces when they did. We have never mentioned it to each other. It remains between us, something sexily unspoken, something as excitingly lurid and darkly mysterious as Bettie is, and as we imagine ourselves to be.
And isn’t that the problem with women like Debbie and Lisa Lynette and even with Amanda from the youth program down at the Baptist church? The teacher, our best friend’s mom, the youth minister’s wife. Nowadays there are real grownup women with itchy britches and antsy pants willing to grab a boy by his you know what and put it any number of you know wheres. Women like that chase the Betties out of our boys’ heads before they are ready for them to go. Women like that take the sexy out of the whole thing. So, what’s a boy left to do? Hook up with some girl from English class (that’s what they call it, hooking up) who is a high-kicker in the high school dance line and get a blow job (which is pretty much what I figure oral sex means to both our kids and our presidents)? It isn't really sexy, but it's what is left.
Debbie and Amanda and Lisa Lynette don't care. They are a little lonely, perhaps somewhat repressed and from Georgia, Florida, Texas. They are Red State gals with ants in their pants and an itch that needs scratching. They are the gals -– a good Republican word, “gals” -- helping elect presidents and save America while they pray for an intelligent design. They are women without mystery and they will always get up off their knees to vote.